Gold Sponsors
Array Telepresence Logo   Human Productivity Lab Logo
Silver Sponsors
Bronze Sponsors
Telepresence Options Magazine

Latest Telepresence and Visual Collaboration News:
Full Article:

The Age of Attending Trade Shows Using Telepresence Robots Has Arrived!

October 31, 2013 | Howard Lichtman

Robotics conference Howard Lichtman David Maldow

Last week Suitable Technologies made history by making 50 of their Beam remote presence devices (which the rest of the world knows as "telepresence robots") available for rental at the RoboConference in Silicon Valley. Telepresence Options publisher Howard Lichtman and editor David Maldow attended using two different Beams to gauge the experience of attending a conference using a "remote presence device".� What we discovered was fascinating and holds important implications for the $100 Billion+ global trade show and conference industry. Get the pros, cons, and logistics of attending your next conference or trade show as a telepresence robot.�

HSL: I attend about a dozen trade shows, conferences, and similar events a year.� I have been giving speeches for years via videoconferencing and telepresence including once using a telepresence podium to address two different audiences in two different cities on the same day. �I rent a Segway every year at the InfoComm trade show to maximize my productivity by trading time spent walking for time spent meeting with clients and partners AND the ability to accelerate myself around the exhibit floor to see twice as much as I would have seen on foot.� I describe the experience as getting two trade shows for the price of a Segway rental.

So... If there was ever a target customer for attending conferences and trade shows more efficiently it would be me.�The ability to attend more events without the cost and pain of physical travel or the inefficiencies of losing so much time-in-transit would be super-impactful to me personally, my business, and my bottom line.

So Telepresence Options editor David Maldow (DSM) and myself (HSL) both jumped at the chance to rent Beam "remote presence devices" (better known as telepresence robots) to attend the first conference in history offering the option to attend using a bot.�

What was the experience like?� How close was it to the usual and customary experience? What is the future of conferences and trade shows if attendees can simply "Beam" in from around the world without physical travel, hotels, and jet lag?

The Logistics

HSL: The first thing both David and I were amazed at was how easy that Suitable Technologies had made the sign up process.� Hit a website, reserve your time, make a payment ($50 Early Bird, $100 Day-of-the-event for all-you-can-drive, first-come-first-served), watch a 2 minute instructional video, sign some electronic documents saying you won't drive the Beam down any stairs or cause other damage. and then you are thrown into a training class by logging on to a Beam robot at Suitable's corporate HQ where a staffer will help you practice your driving skills and give you some tips for maximizing the experience:� The Beam bot has a party mode where it cranks up the volume of the remote operator to make him easier to hear over the din of the trade show floor and how to share your screen on the bot's display.

After your training you are then approved to login to the Beam on the day of the event.

The Experience

HSL: When you login there are a variety of Beams to choose from and, I assume, had the venue been larger that we would have gotten to choose what section of the event would we like to have liked to have started from.� The Beam comes alive in a rack of about 10 and as you move your Beam out you are greeted by a suitable technologies rep who answers any questions and points you in the right direction.� The Beams have had their speed reduced from a top speed of 3 miles per hour down to 0.5mph to ensure safety for the human attendees.� For comparison the average human walking speed is about 3.1 mph.�

DSM: In the dark ages of visual collaboration, videoconferencing was completely location-based, not person-based. In other words, VC existed in board rooms because it was expensive and complicated. Rooms called rooms, people didn't call people.

The undeniable fact is, sometimes you still want to call a location, not a person. If I can't make it to the big board meeting, I don't want to just call an attendee's tablet or phone. I want real "presence" in that room. I want to call THE ROOM, not the person. That may mean that I am attending via a Beam or other remote presence device, or that I am presented full sized, across the table, telepresence style. The key is that I am presenting myself as an actual meeting participant, not someone just "calling in".

In the end, that is the truly compelling element of the Beam experience. It really is "remote presence" in the most literal sense of the words. I have called into tradeshows via video before, but this was different. I didn't feel like I was calling in. I felt like I was attending this conference. This effected how I interacted with other attendees, how they interacted with me, and how much I was able to really accomplish and learn at the event.

Interestingly, Beam founder, Scott Hassan vehemently denies that his product is a robot. While the rest of the mobile remote presence vendors are happily selling robots, and despite the fact that the Beam looks like something out of a Pixar robot movie, the Beam is absolutely not a robot. I didn't get it either at first, but now it makes perfect sense. Scott explained that the goal isn't for you to drive a Beam around the show all day. The goal is to have hundreds (or thousands) of Beams all over the show, allowing you to simply "Beam" from device to device, from booth to booth. Why drive when you can just zap yourself there?

This is Scott's dream. He understands that only kids and geeks (like yours truly) want to drive robots all day. Business people simply want to (yes I will say it again) "Beam" to a location, meet with people, and get work done. Scott isn't trying to create R2D2 from Star Wars, he is trying to create the teleportation device from Star Trek (the very obvious source of the product's name). "Beam me up Scotty" indeed!

The Pros

You Run Into People You Know Just Like a Real Conference�

Robotics conference Beam Robot

HSL:� I had a couple of people I know come up to me as I was cruising through the conference.� Erin Rapacki, General Manager of Industrial Perception, who I interviewed years ago when she was with telepresence robotics pioneer AnyBots who introduced me to her friend Sam Bouchard the President of RobotIQ.� I also ran into Marcus Rosenthal, CEO of Revolve Robotics, that is developing a robotic head and neck platform for the iPad called the Kubi to improve videoconferencing.

... And have Spontaneous Interactions

Robotics conference Beam Robot

When I ran into Revolve Robotics' CEO Marcus Rosenthal at the reception he fished out the first production Kubi from his backpack and put on an impromptu demonstration.� In the photo montage (top left) you can see me in a videoconference with the iPad on the Kubi on the table. �Both Blue Jeans and Zoom have created applications for the Kubi that allow you to easily control the Kubi.� This was my first time to try both and you can see the Zoom app at the bottom left and the Blue Jeans app on the top right.�� The bottom right image is a screen grab from the laptop I was using to connect with the Kubi which I positioned from afar to capture me on the Beam.�

It's Easy to Meet New People when you are a Telepresence Robot

Robotics conference Beam Robot

I was amazed at how easy it was to meet people while driving the Beam.� I know there is some novelty right now but everyone (with the exception of the guy in the anecdote a couple of paragraphs down) was warm and friendly and conversations were quite natural.� In the picture on the right I am talking to Bing Jiang, the founder of Rolling Robots who was also attending via a rented Beam.� Bing took a photo of me and my 9 year old son during the reception (hence the glass of wine) from her Beam and emailed it to me.

The Cons

Robotics conference Beam Robot

You're Not Really There - HSL: Obviously not the fault of the Beam, but this is one of the trade-offs of attending using remote presence.� No buffet, no shaking hands, no hugs, no shwag, no parties, etc.

The Speed - HSL: I understand, since this was the first time a conference has ever made 50 remote presence devices available for rental, that the focus was on ensuring safety but limiting the Beams to a top speed of � a mile an hour was sloooww.� Maybe I am just used to bombing around InfoComm on the Segway at 9 miles per hour but I hope that Suitable is working on collision avoidance features that will allow them to crank up the speed.

Everyone Looks the Same:� HSL: I was trying to find David in the crowd, but alas, every remote attendee looks the same from the back, side, or any direction that is not head on.�

You Still Have to Actively Drive It Around - DSM: The issue isn't that it is hard to drive, but the fact that you have to drive it at all. While the mobility is amazing for checking out booths and just simply looking around and engaging with people, there were times I was wishing for an autopilot, or at least an autofollow, as I dutifully followed Howard's Beam around the show. While the Beam team refused to talk about wish lists and roadmaps (whether I was asking about navigation or other features), their eyes positively lit up as they refused to talk. I don't know what exactly to expect, but I am definitely looking forward to seeing it.

Interesting Experiences

The Tradeshow Job Seeker of the Future - HSL: While piloting my Beam through the hall I overheard a fascinating conversation from someone else who had rented a Beam.� He was a roboticist that had just graduated college and was looking for work.� He rented the Beam and was going booth-to-booth talking with prospective companies.� He generated a QR code for the link to his on-line resume which he would share out on the screen of the Beam where interested employers could snap a picture with their smart phone.

Some People Don't Like Remote Presence Devices - HSL: At one point I stopped my Beam in the middle of an aisle to send a quick IM on another laptop I was using simultaneously.� I hear someone next to the Beam exclaim: "Hold On... I don't want our conversation recorded by this F#@&ing robot".� I thought it was an interesting comment and, as a journalist, I wanted to ask him about it so I rotated the Beam around.� The guy put his hand over my Beam's camera, finished his conversation, and then walked away.��� Later on that evening I was letting my 11 year old pilot the Beam and I instructed him to park it against a wall for a minute.� I hear him exclaim: "Dad! Someone just threw a chair in front of the robot".� I went over to the screen and it was the same guy who had covered up my camera.� I told my son to go around the chair and then the� guy came running back and threw another chair in front of the Beam on the other side to block the way again.�

The Future

Robotics conference Beam Robot

Beam's CEO Scott Hassan interviewed using a Beam

We interviewed Suitable Technologies CEO Scott Hassan on the future of renting Beams at conferences and trade shows.� Scott's goal is to have 10,000 Beams available for rental at the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in 2015.� The event which attracts north of 150,000 attendees from around the world and covers over 1.87 million square feet of space would be challenging for navigating by bot but Scott's plan is to enable those interested to use multiple Beams simultaneously for each attendee.� As you are meeting with a company at Booth #1, a driver is piloting Beam#2 to Booth#2 while a separate driver pilots Beam#3 to booth #3.� Instead of six 30 minute meetings and two hours of walking, you can do ten 30 minute meetings with no walking, airfare, or hotel.� We are assuming that Beam pilots can be cost-effectively sourced using a labor arbitrage engine like Amazon's Mechanical Turk which has a large virtual workforce on tap for human intelligence projects like... piloting Beams around CES.

Can You Cover a Trade Show Effectively as a Journalist Using the Beam?

While our expertise is primarily in telepresence robotics and visual collaboration, we were excited to get to learn more about pure robotics at the conference and test the Beam's capabilities for remote journalists.� Our Strategy: We asked every attendee that we met what was the coolest things they saw at the show and then visited the booth and asked some questions:

Unbounded Robotics - UBR-1

Robotics conference Beam Robot

Unbounded Robotics, a spinoff of Willow Garage which spawned the Beam as well, recently debuted its first machine, UBR-1, a $35,000 head and multi-jointed robotic arm on wheels that runs on the open-source Robot Operating System, or ROS.� The company won the "Pitchfire" award at the conference where venture capitalists judged their "pitch" as the best of the robotic bunch.� We spoke with founder and CTO Michael Ferguson who explained the UBR-1 as a, relatively, low-cost platform for research and education, developing robotic apps, and picking, kiting, & packaging applications.

NPC Robotics - Landrone

Robotics conference Beam Robot

The Landrone was cool: It is essentially a robotic base for first responders that can swap out "tops" depending on the mission.� The $30-50K base can carry up to 1000 lbs or pull a full-size truck.� The blue box in Mike's hand is a component pack demonstrating how easy field maintenance is (just replace the blue pack).� The device in Mike's other hand is a "Net Gun" that can be attached and fired which will take down a full size elk.� We tried to get Mike to demonstrate the Net Gun for our cameras but, alas, they had disarmed it for the conference.

Rethink Robotics - Baxter

Robotics conference Beam Robot

Baxter is an interactive production robot and collaborative manufacturing robot that starts at $22K and tops out at $30K with a pedestal, 2nd set of grippers, and a 3 year warranty.� The robot is called a "collaborative manufacturing robot" because it is designed to operate around people and doesn't require a safety cage. It has multiple sensors and can detect an imminent collision with a human and stop / back up immediately.� It is designed for lifting small objects repetitively, kiting, packaging, and assembly.� It is manually trainable so you just need to demonstrate the required action by manipulating the arm in the desired motion and the robot will learn that action.��

About the Authors

Howard_headshot.jpgHoward Lichtman is the Founder and President of the Human Productivity Lab, a consulting firm that helps organizations design visual collaboration strategies, build Video Network Operation Centers (VNOCs), and helps with RFP creation, bid management, and oversight. He is the publisher of Telepresence Options, the leading publication covering visual collaboration where he and his team share the lessons learned from real world deployments and cover the industry's latest advacements.


David_Maldow, Esq.David Maldow, Esq. is a visual collaboration technologist and analyst with the Human Productivity Lab and an associate publisher at Telepresence Options. David has extensive expertise in testing, evaluating, and explaining telepresence and other visual collaboration / rich media solutions. David is focused on providing third-party independent analysis and opinion of these technologies and helping end users better secure their visual collaboration environments. You can follow David on Twitter and Google+.







Add New Comment

Telepresence Options welcomes your comments! You may comment using your name and email (which will not be displayed), or you may connect with your Twitter, Facebook, Google+, or DISQUS account.